The Dyson Big Ball and Shark Navigator series represent two of the most popular upright vacuum cleaner lines on the market. Both brands have earned a reputation for powerful suction, innovative features, and effective cleaning across various floor types. Dyson, with its Big Ball technology, emphasizes self-righting capabilities and consistent performance, while Shark’s Navigator boasts its signature Lift-Away design for enhanced versatility. Deciding between these two vacuum titans can be challenging, as both offer compelling advantages depending on your specific cleaning needs and preferences.
This review dives deep into the specifics of the Dyson Big Ball and Shark Navigator, comparing their design, performance, features, and overall value. We’ll analyze their strengths and weaknesses to help you determine which upright vacuum is the best fit for your home. Whether you prioritize advanced technology, versatile cleaning options, or raw suction power, this comprehensive comparison will provide the insights you need to make an informed decision.
Table of Contents
Key Takeaways
- Dyson Big Ball: Superior filtration, self-righting design, and consistent suction make it ideal for allergy sufferers and those seeking hassle-free operation. However, it comes at a premium price. Verdict: 8.5/10
- Shark Navigator: Offers excellent value with its Lift-Away feature, strong suction, and versatile cleaning attachments. However, it can be heavier and less maneuverable than the Dyson. Verdict: 8.0/10
Specifications
| Feature | Dyson Big Ball | Shark Navigator |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Upright | Upright |
| Technology | Big Ball self-righting | Lift-Away |
| Weight | ~17.2 lbs | ~12.5-16 lbs (depending on the specific Navigator model) |
| Cord Length | ~35 ft | ~25-30 ft (depending on the specific Navigator model) |
| Filtration | Whole-machine HEPA filtration | HEPA filtration (some models) |
| Dust Cup Capacity | 0.53 gallons | ~1.2-2.2 quarts (depending on the specific Navigator model) |
| Attachments | Combination tool, stair tool | Crevice tool, dusting brush, pet power brush (model dependent) |
| Swivel Steering | Yes | Yes |
| Cleaning Path Width | ~10.6 inches | ~9.5-12 inches (depending on the specific Navigator model) |
| Warranty | 5 years | 1-5 years (depending on the specific Navigator model) |
Price and Availability
- Dyson Big Ball: Typically ranges from \$300-\$500, available at major retailers like Dyson’s website, Amazon, Best Buy, and department stores.
- Shark Navigator: Price varies significantly depending on the specific model, ranging from \$150-\$300. Widely available at retailers such as Amazon, Walmart, Target, and department stores.
Design and Build Quality
The Dyson Big Ball stands out with its spherical design, allowing it to self-right when toppled over. This feature is not just a gimmick; it genuinely improves the user experience by preventing interruptions during cleaning. The materials used in the Dyson Big Ball feel premium and durable, reflecting its higher price point. The overall construction exudes quality, with well-fitted parts and a solid feel. However, its weight can be a drawback for some users, especially when carrying it up stairs.
In contrast, the Shark Navigator adopts a more traditional upright vacuum design but introduces the Lift-Away feature, allowing the canister to detach from the main unit for portable cleaning. This design offers versatility, making it easier to clean stairs, upholstery, and hard-to-reach areas. While the build quality of the Shark Navigator is generally good, it doesn’t quite match the premium feel of the Dyson Big Ball. The plastic components feel less robust, although they are still durable enough for regular use. The Shark Navigator’s weight varies depending on the specific model, but it is generally lighter than the Dyson Big Ball, making it easier to maneuver for some users.
Performance and Features
Suction Power
Both the Dyson Big Ball and Shark Navigator are renowned for their strong suction power. The Dyson Big Ball utilizes its Radial Root Cyclone technology to generate powerful centrifugal forces, effectively capturing dirt and debris from carpets and hard floors. Dyson claims that its technology maintains consistent suction power, even as the dust bin fills up.
The Shark Navigator also boasts impressive suction, often rivaling the Dyson in head-to-head tests. The Navigator’s suction is particularly effective on carpets, where it can lift embedded dirt and pet hair with ease. However, some users have reported that the Shark Navigator’s suction can be too strong on delicate rugs or hard floors, requiring adjustment of the suction control settings (if available on the specific model).
Filtration
Filtration is a critical aspect of vacuum cleaner performance, especially for allergy sufferers. The Dyson Big Ball features whole-machine HEPA filtration, meaning that the entire vacuum is sealed to prevent allergens and dust from escaping. This is a significant advantage for those with sensitivities, as it ensures that the air expelled by the vacuum is clean and allergen-free.
While many Shark Navigator models include HEPA filtration, not all offer whole-machine filtration. This means that some models may release a small amount of dust and allergens back into the air. If filtration is a top priority, it’s essential to check the specifications of the specific Shark Navigator model you are considering.
Maneuverability
The Dyson Big Ball’s unique design contributes to its excellent maneuverability. The ball allows the vacuum to turn and pivot smoothly, making it easy to navigate around furniture and obstacles. However, its weight can make it challenging to push across thick carpets for extended periods.
The Shark Navigator also offers good maneuverability, thanks to its swivel steering. The Lift-Away feature further enhances its versatility, allowing you to detach the canister and carry it separately while cleaning stairs or other elevated surfaces. However, some users find the Shark Navigator to be less agile than the Dyson Big Ball, especially in tight spaces.
Attachments and Accessories
The Dyson Big Ball typically includes a combination tool and a stair tool, which are useful for cleaning upholstery, crevices, and stairs. However, some users may find the attachment selection to be limited compared to the Shark Navigator.
The Shark Navigator often comes with a wider range of attachments, including a crevice tool, dusting brush, and pet power brush. The pet power brush is particularly effective for removing pet hair from carpets and upholstery. The availability of these attachments varies depending on the specific Navigator model.
Battery Life
Since both the Dyson Big Ball and Shark Navigator are corded vacuums, battery life is not a relevant factor. The cord length is an important consideration, as it determines the vacuum’s reach. The Dyson Big Ball typically has a longer cord length than the Shark Navigator, providing greater freedom of movement.
Software and User Experience
As traditional upright vacuums, neither the Dyson Big Ball nor the Shark Navigator relies heavily on software. The user experience is primarily determined by the design, features, and ease of use.
The Dyson Big Ball is known for its simple and intuitive operation. The self-righting feature and consistent suction power contribute to a hassle-free cleaning experience. However, some users may find the dust bin emptying process to be less convenient compared to the Shark Navigator.
The Shark Navigator’s Lift-Away feature enhances its versatility and ease of use, allowing you to quickly switch between upright and portable cleaning modes. The dust bin is typically easy to empty, and the controls are straightforward.
Comparison to Competitors
Dyson Big Ball vs. Shark Navigator vs. Bissell CleanView
- Dyson Big Ball: Excels in filtration and maneuverability, but is more expensive.
- Shark Navigator: Offers excellent value and versatility, but may lack the premium feel of the Dyson.
- Bissell CleanView: A budget-friendly option with decent suction, but lacks advanced features and may not be as durable.
Dyson Big Ball vs. Shark Navigator vs. Hoover WindTunnel
- Dyson Big Ball: Superior filtration and self-righting design.
- Shark Navigator: More versatile with the Lift-Away feature and a wider range of attachments.
- Hoover WindTunnel: A mid-range option with good suction and a self-propelled feature, but can be bulky and heavy.
Pros and Cons
Dyson Big Ball
Pros:
- Superior filtration with whole-machine HEPA
- Self-righting design
- Consistent suction power
- Excellent maneuverability
- Durable build quality
- Longer cord length
Cons:
- Higher price point
- Can be heavy for some users
- Limited attachment selection
Shark Navigator
Pros:
- Lift-Away feature for versatile cleaning
- Strong suction power
- Good value for money
- Wide range of attachments (model dependent)
- Lighter than the Dyson Big Ball
- Easy-to-empty dust bin
Cons:
- Build quality not as premium as the Dyson
- Filtration may not be whole-machine HEPA
- Can be less maneuverable in tight spaces
- Suction may be too strong on delicate surfaces
Value for Money
The Dyson Big Ball is a premium vacuum cleaner that offers advanced features and superior performance. However, its higher price point may not be justifiable for all users. If you prioritize filtration, maneuverability, and a hassle-free cleaning experience, the Dyson Big Ball may be worth the investment.
The Shark Navigator, on the other hand, provides excellent value for money. Its Lift-Away feature, strong suction, and versatile attachments make it a compelling option for those seeking a versatile and effective vacuum cleaner at a more affordable price.
Verdict
The Dyson Big Ball and Shark Navigator are both excellent upright vacuum cleaners that offer strong suction and effective cleaning performance. The Dyson Big Ball stands out with its superior filtration, self-righting design, and premium build quality, making it ideal for allergy sufferers and those seeking a hassle-free cleaning experience. However, its higher price point may be a barrier for some.
The Shark Navigator offers excellent value for money with its Lift-Away feature, strong suction, and versatile attachments. It’s a great option for those seeking a versatile and effective vacuum cleaner at a more affordable price. Ultimately, the best choice depends on your specific needs, preferences, and budget.
- Dyson Big Ball: 8.5/10
- Shark Navigator: 8.0/10
