The Shark Navigator and Dyson DC50 represent two distinct approaches to lightweight vacuum cleaner design. The Shark Navigator aims for affordability and versatility, offering powerful suction and a range of attachments in a maneuverable package. The Dyson DC50, on the other hand, emphasizes compact design and advanced cyclonic technology, targeting users who value portability and filtration performance. Both vacuums compete in the crowded market of upright vacuums, each with its own strengths and weaknesses.
This review will provide a detailed comparison of the Shark Navigator and Dyson DC50, covering aspects such as design, build quality, performance, features, and value for money. By examining these factors, we aim to help you make an informed decision based on your specific cleaning needs and preferences. We’ll delve into real-world usage scenarios and provide data-driven analysis to highlight the nuances of each vacuum.
Table of Contents
Key Takeaways
- Shark Navigator: Offers excellent suction power for its price, versatile with its lift-away feature, but can be bulky to store.
- Dyson DC50: Compact and lightweight, boasts advanced cyclonic filtration, but has a smaller dustbin capacity.
- Performance: The Shark Navigator generally delivers stronger suction on carpets, while the Dyson DC50 excels in maneuverability and filtration.
- Value: The Shark Navigator typically offers better value for money due to its lower price point and comparable performance.
- Verdict: Both are viable options, but the Shark Navigator leans toward budget-conscious buyers needing strong suction, while the Dyson DC50 suits those prioritizing a lightweight, compact design with advanced filtration, giving a score of 7.8/10.
Specifications
| Feature | Shark Navigator | Dyson DC50 |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Upright, Lift-Away | Upright |
| Weight | ~13 lbs | ~11.6 lbs |
| Dustbin Capacity | ~1.2 quarts | |
| Cord Length | ~25-30 ft | ~21 ft |
| Filtration | HEPA filter, Anti-Allergen Complete Seal Technology | HEPA filter, Radial Root Cycloneâ„¢ technology |
| Attachments | Crevice tool, dusting brush, pet power brush | Combination tool, stair tool |
| Suction Power | 1200 watts | 130 Air Watts |
| Dimensions | Varies by model | 11 x 13.8 x 43.3 inches |
| Cleaning Path Width | ~9.5 inches | ~8.27 inches |
| Swivel Steering | Yes | Yes |
| Bagless | Yes | Yes |
| Warranty | 1-5 year (varies by model) | 5 years (parts and labor) |
Price and Availability
The Shark Navigator’s price typically ranges from $150 to $250, depending on the specific model and retailer. It is widely available at major retailers such as Amazon, Walmart, Target, and directly from the SharkClean website. Keep an eye out for deals, especially during holiday sales events like Black Friday and Cyber Monday.
The Dyson DC50 generally costs between $300 and $400. It can be purchased from Dyson’s website, as well as retailers like Amazon, Best Buy, and department stores such as Macy’s and Nordstrom. Bundles including additional attachments are sometimes available.
Design and Build Quality
The Shark Navigator features a lift-away design, allowing the canister to detach from the main unit for easier cleaning of stairs and upholstery. The build quality is decent, with durable plastic components. However, some users find it slightly bulky compared to other lightweight vacuums. The swivel steering enhances maneuverability around furniture.
The Dyson DC50 stands out with its compact and lightweight design. It uses high-quality materials and feels sturdy despite its small size. The ball technology allows for smooth and precise steering. The DC50’s compact footprint makes it easy to store in tight spaces. Comparing the two, the Dyson DC50 feels more premium in hand, while the Shark Navigator prioritizes versatility with its lift-away feature.
Build Quality Comparison
The Shark Navigator uses more plastic in its construction, which contributes to its lower price point. While the plastic is durable, it doesn’t have the same premium feel as the Dyson DC50’s materials. The Dyson DC50 incorporates more robust components and tighter tolerances, resulting in a more refined finish.
Ergonomics
Both vacuums are designed with user ergonomics in mind. The Shark Navigator’s lift-away feature reduces strain when cleaning above-floor areas. However, its larger size can make it slightly cumbersome for some users. The Dyson DC50’s lightweight design and ball technology make it exceptionally easy to maneuver, reducing fatigue during extended cleaning sessions.
Performance and Features
The Shark Navigator is known for its powerful suction, which effectively removes dirt and debris from carpets and hard floors. The brush roll can be turned on or off, making it suitable for various floor types. The lift-away feature allows for convenient cleaning of stairs and upholstery.
The Dyson DC50 utilizes Radial Root Cycloneâ„¢ technology, which provides strong suction and efficient dirt separation. This technology helps prevent clogging and maintains consistent suction power over time. The DC50 is particularly effective at capturing fine dust and allergens.
Suction Power
The Shark Navigator boasts high suction power, making it effective at deep cleaning carpets. In standardized tests, it often outperforms the Dyson DC50 in terms of raw suction force. However, the Dyson DC50’s cyclonic technology ensures consistent suction, even as the dustbin fills up.
Filtration
Both vacuums feature HEPA filters, which capture 99.97% of particles as small as 0.3 microns. The Shark Navigator uses Anti-Allergen Complete Seal Technology to trap dust and allergens inside the vacuum. The Dyson DC50’s Radial Root Cycloneâ„¢ technology enhances filtration by separating dirt and dust particles before they reach the filter.
Attachments and Accessories
The Shark Navigator typically comes with a crevice tool, dusting brush, and pet power brush. These attachments enhance its versatility for cleaning various surfaces and removing pet hair. The Dyson DC50 includes a combination tool and stair tool, which are useful for cleaning edges, crevices, and stairs.
Battery Life
Since both the Shark Navigator and Dyson DC50 are corded vacuums, battery life is not applicable. The cord length of the Shark Navigator is approximately 25-30 feet, while the Dyson DC50’s cord is around 21 feet.
Software and User Experience
Neither the Shark Navigator nor the Dyson DC50 have software or app-based features. The user experience is straightforward, with simple controls and intuitive operation. Both vacuums are easy to assemble and disassemble for cleaning and maintenance.
Comparison to Competitors
Dyson Ball Multi Floor 2
The Dyson Ball Multi Floor 2 is another popular Dyson vacuum that competes with the DC50 and Shark Navigator. It offers similar cyclonic technology and maneuverability but has a larger dustbin capacity than the DC50. However, it is also more expensive than both the DC50 and Shark Navigator.
Bissell CleanView
The Bissell CleanView is a budget-friendly option that competes with the Shark Navigator. It offers strong suction and a range of attachments but lacks the lift-away feature and HEPA filtration found in the Shark Navigator. The Bissell CleanView is a good choice for users who prioritize affordability over advanced features.
Pros and Cons
Shark Navigator
- Pros: Strong suction, lift-away feature, affordable, versatile attachments
- Cons: Can be bulky, build quality could be better, shorter warranty
Dyson DC50
- Pros: Lightweight and compact, excellent maneuverability, advanced cyclonic filtration
- Cons: Smaller dustbin capacity, more expensive, less powerful suction than some competitors
Value for Money
The Shark Navigator offers excellent value for money due to its strong suction power, versatile features, and affordable price point. It is a great option for users who want a powerful and versatile vacuum without breaking the bank.
The Dyson DC50 is more expensive than the Shark Navigator but offers a more refined design, superior maneuverability, and advanced cyclonic filtration. It is a good choice for users who prioritize these features and are willing to pay a premium.
Who Should Buy Each Vacuum?
Shark Navigator: Ideal for budget-conscious buyers who need strong suction and versatility for cleaning various surfaces, including carpets, hard floors, and upholstery.
Dyson DC50: Best suited for users who prioritize a lightweight, compact design, excellent maneuverability, and advanced filtration for capturing fine dust and allergens.
Verdict
Both the Shark Navigator and Dyson DC50 are capable vacuum cleaners with their own strengths and weaknesses. The Shark Navigator offers excellent suction power and versatility at an affordable price. The Dyson DC50 stands out with its compact design, maneuverability, and advanced filtration.
Ultimately, the choice between these two vacuums depends on your specific needs and priorities. If you prioritize strong suction and versatility and are on a budget, the Shark Navigator is a great choice. If you value a lightweight, compact design, superior maneuverability, and advanced filtration, the Dyson DC50 is worth the investment. Given these considerations, we rate both options and the Dyson DC50 gets a score of 7.8/10.
