Robot vacuums have become essential tools for maintaining clean floors with minimal effort. Among the numerous options, the Roomba i4 and Shark IQ UR100S stand out as popular choices for budget-conscious consumers seeking effective cleaning and smart features. These models promise to automate the chore of vacuuming, offering convenience and consistent performance. Deciding between the Roomba i4 and the Shark IQ UR100S requires a close examination of their strengths and weaknesses to determine which one aligns best with your specific cleaning needs and home environment.
Shark AV2610WA Robot Vacuum & Mop Combo Powerful Suction Matrix Plus
Shark Matrix Plus 2in1 Robot Vacuum & Mop with Sonic Mopping (AV2613WA)
Both the Roomba i4 and Shark IQ UR100S cater to busy individuals, pet owners, and anyone looking to simplify their cleaning routine. They compete in the mid-range robot vacuum market, offering a balance of features and affordability. The Roomba i4, known for its reliable cleaning performance and smart navigation, appeals to users who prioritize brand reputation and a user-friendly experience. On the other hand, the Shark IQ UR100S attracts those seeking a self-emptying base at a competitive price point, along with strong suction and effective pet hair removal. Ultimately, the right choice depends on factors like floor type, pet ownership, desired level of automation, and budget considerations.
Table of Contents
- Quick Verdict
- Short Review of the Roomba i4
- Short Review of the Shark IQ UR100S
- Key Differences at a Glance
- Specifications Comparison
- Price Comparison
- Design and Build Quality
- Performance Face-Off
- Special Features Comparison
- Usability and User Experience
- Maintenance and Longevity
- Who Should Buy the Roomba i4?
- Who Should Buy the Shark IQ UR100S?
- Final Recommendation
Quick Verdict
- For pet owners: The Roomba i4 is better, with dual rubber brushes that prevent hair tangles.
- For hard floors: The Shark IQ UR100S has superior performance.
- For low-pile carpets: The Shark IQ UR100S has superior performance.
- For large homes: The Shark IQ UR100S due to its self-emptying bin.
- For smart navigation: The Roomba i4 has more efficient navigation.
- For obstacle maneuvering: The Roomba i4 does a better job.
Short Review of the Roomba i4
The Roomba i4 is a reliable and efficient robot vacuum designed to provide consistent cleaning performance across various floor types. Equipped with iRobot’s signature features, such as Dirt Detect technology and dual multi-surface rubber brushes, the i4 effectively tackles dirt, dust, and pet hair. Its smart navigation system ensures thorough coverage, while its compatibility with the iRobot Home app allows for convenient scheduling and control. The Roomba i4 is particularly well-suited for homes with a mix of hard floors and carpets, offering a balanced cleaning approach.
One of the standout features of the Roomba i4 is its ease of use and maintenance. The dual rubber brushes are designed to resist tangling, making it an excellent choice for pet owners. The iRobot Home app provides a seamless user experience, allowing users to customize cleaning schedules and monitor the robot’s progress. While it may lack some of the advanced features found in higher-end models, the Roomba i4 delivers a solid cleaning performance and a user-friendly experience, making it a great value for its price.
Short Review of the Shark IQ UR100S
The Shark IQ UR100S is a feature-rich robot vacuum that combines powerful suction with a self-emptying base, offering a convenient and hands-free cleaning experience. Its IQ Navigation system ensures methodical cleaning, while its self-cleaning brushroll minimizes hair tangles. The UR100S excels at picking up dirt, dust, and pet hair on both hard floors and carpets. The self-emptying base can hold weeks’ worth of debris, reducing the frequency of manual emptying.
The Shark IQ UR100S stands out for its value proposition, offering many features typically found in higher-end models at a more affordable price. Its strong suction and effective brushroll make it a capable cleaner, while the self-emptying base adds a significant level of convenience. The SharkClean app allows for scheduling and control, although some users may find it less intuitive than the iRobot Home app. Overall, the Shark IQ UR100S is a compelling option for those seeking a robot vacuum with advanced features and a budget-friendly price tag.
Key Differences at a Glance
- Self-Emptying Base: The Shark IQ UR100S includes a self-emptying base, while the Roomba i4 does not (though a similar model, the i4+, does).
- Brushroll Design: The Roomba i4 features dual multi-surface rubber brushes, while the Shark IQ UR100S has a self-cleaning brushroll.
- Navigation Technology: The Roomba i4 uses iRobot’s smart navigation, while the Shark IQ UR100S employs IQ Navigation.
- Dustbin Capacity: The Shark IQ UR100S has a larger on-board dustbin capacity than the Roomba i4.
- App Interface: The Roomba i4 uses the iRobot Home app, while the Shark IQ UR100S uses the SharkClean app.
- Bare Floor Cleaning: The Shark IQ Robot performs better on bare floors.
- Low Pile Carpet Cleaning: The Shark IQ Robot performs better on low-pile carpets.
Specifications Comparison
| Feature | Roomba i4 | Shark IQ UR100S |
|---|---|---|
| Navigation | Smart Navigation | IQ Navigation |
| Brushroll Type | Dual Multi-Surface Rubber Brushes | Self-Cleaning Brushroll |
| Self-Emptying Base | No (available in i4+ model) | Yes |
| Dustbin Capacity (Robot) | Not Specified | Not Specified |
| App Control | iRobot Home App | SharkClean App |
| Battery Life | Up to 75 minutes | Up to 90 minutes |
| Recharge Time | ~3 hours | ~6 hours |
| Voice Control | Yes (with Alexa and Google Assistant) | Yes (with Alexa and Google Assistant) |
| Room Mapping | Yes | Yes |
| Dirt Detect Technology | Yes | No |
| Allergen Filtration | HEPA Filter | HEPA Filter |
| Dimensions | 13.4 inches diameter, 3.6 inches height | 12.9 inches diameter, 3.5 inches height |
| Weight | 6.81 lbs | 7.7 lbs |
Price Comparison
The Roomba i4 typically retails for around $300-$350, while the Shark IQ UR100S generally costs between $350-$400. However, prices may vary depending on retailer and promotions. The Shark IQ UR100S offers a strong value proposition due to its inclusion of a self-emptying base, which is typically found in more expensive models. While the Roomba i4 may be slightly cheaper upfront, the added convenience of the self-emptying base in the Shark IQ UR100S can justify the higher price for many users.
Considering the cost-to-feature ratio, the Shark IQ UR100S provides more features for the price, particularly with its self-emptying base. However, if a self-emptying base is not a priority, the Roomba i4 offers a more affordable entry point into the world of robot vacuums. Ultimately, the best value depends on individual needs and preferences.
Design and Build Quality
Both the Roomba i4 and Shark IQ UR100S feature a similar circular design common among robot vacuums. The Roomba i4 has a sleek, minimalist aesthetic with a matte finish. The Shark IQ UR100S has a more utilitarian look with a glossy finish and a larger self-emptying base.
In terms of build quality, the Roomba i4 feels more robust and durable. Its construction is solid, and its components appear to be of higher quality. The Shark IQ UR100S, while still well-built, has a slightly more plasticky feel. The Roomba i4 also has better maneuverability around obstacles. Both vacuums are relatively low-profile and can fit under most furniture.
Performance Face-Off
Cleaning Performance on Hard Floors
The Shark IQ UR100S demonstrates superior cleaning performance on hard floors, effectively capturing pet hair and small debris like rice. However, it may struggle with larger debris as its dirt compartment fills up. The Roomba i4 also performs well on hard floors, effectively handling both large and small debris, though it may have some difficulty with debris accumulated in corners and along walls.
Cleaning Performance on Carpets
The Roomba i4 has better cleaning performance on carpets, specifically low and high-pile carpets. The Shark IQ UR100S also delivers a fair overall performance on carpets, though it may struggle more with finer debris.
Pet Hair Cleaning
Both vacuums are designed to handle pet hair, but the Roomba i4 has dual multi-surface rubber brushes that prevent hair tangles. The Shark IQ UR100S features a self-cleaning brushroll, but it may require occasional maintenance to remove wrapped hair.
Navigation and Coverage
The Roomba i4 has smart navigation, efficiently cleaning in an orderly pattern. It utilizes Reactive Sensor Technology to avoid obstacles. The Shark IQ UR100S uses IQ Navigation, which cleans each room row-by-row for complete coverage.
Special Features Comparison
- Roomba i4: Dirt Detect Technology, which focuses on dirtier areas.
- Shark IQ UR100S: Self-Emptying Base, which holds weeks of dirt and debris.
Usability and User Experience
Both the Roomba i4 and Shark IQ UR100S are designed for ease of use, but the Roomba i4 has a more intuitive app interface. The iRobot Home app is user-friendly and offers a seamless experience for scheduling and customization. The SharkClean app is functional, but it can be less intuitive. The self-emptying base of the Shark IQ UR100S adds convenience, reducing the frequency of manual emptying.
Maintenance and Longevity
The Roomba i4 has fewer recurring costs and is easy to maintain. The Shark IQ UR100S has more parts that require regular maintenance or periodic replacement, potentially leading to higher recurring costs over time.
Who Should Buy the Roomba i4?
The Roomba i4 is a good choice for:
- Those who prefer a trusted brand with a strong reputation.
- Homes with a mix of hard floors and carpets.
- Pet owners who want a vacuum with tangle-resistant brushes.
- Users who value a user-friendly app interface.
Who Should Buy the Shark IQ UR100S?
The Shark IQ UR100S is a good choice for:
- Those who want a self-emptying base at a competitive price.
- Homes with mostly hard floors.
- Users who want strong suction power.
- Those seeking a feature-rich robot vacuum at a budget-friendly price.
Final Recommendation
Both the Roomba i4 and Shark IQ UR100S are capable robot vacuums that offer convenience and effective cleaning. However, the Shark IQ UR100S emerges as the better overall value due to its inclusion of a self-emptying base and strong performance on hard floors, making it an excellent choice for those who prioritize convenience and affordability. If you prefer a trusted brand, have mostly carpets and want a more user-friendly app interface, the Roomba i4 is also a solid choice.
