The Dyson DC17 and Shark NV26 Navigator represent two distinct approaches to tackling household dirt. The Dyson DC17, known for its Root Cyclone technology, offers powerful suction and whole-machine HEPA filtration, targeting allergy sufferers. The Shark NV26 Navigator, on the other hand, provides a lighter, more maneuverable option with its swivel steering and brushroll shutoff feature, making it suitable for various floor types. Both vacuums aim to deliver a thorough cleaning experience, but their strengths lie in different areas.
In a market saturated with cleaning solutions, choosing the right vacuum can be daunting. The Dyson DC17 promises uncompromising suction and advanced filtration, while the Shark NV26 Navigator focuses on ease of use and versatility. This review will dive deep into their design, performance, features, and overall value to help you determine which vacuum best fits your cleaning needs.
Table of Contents
Key Takeaways
- Suction Power: Dyson DC17 excels in raw suction power, effectively lifting embedded dirt and debris.
- Maneuverability: Shark NV26 Navigator offers superior maneuverability with its lightweight design and swivel steering.
- Filtration: Dyson DC17 provides whole-machine HEPA filtration, ideal for allergy and asthma sufferers.
- Versatility: Shark NV26 Navigator’s brushroll shutoff allows for seamless transition between carpets and hard floors.
- Value: Shark NV26 Navigator typically offers a more budget-friendly option compared to the Dyson DC17.
Specifications
| Feature | Dyson DC17 | Shark NV26 Navigator |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Upright | Upright |
| Weight | 21.8 lbs | 15 lbs |
| Dimensions | 13.5 x 14.2 x 48.2 inches | 12 x 10 x 45.5 inches |
| Suction Power | 220 Air Watts | Not Specified |
| Filtration | HEPA, Lifetime Filter | Standard, Washable Filter |
| Dust Cup Capacity | 0.61 gallons | 0.26 gallons |
| Cord Length | 31 feet | 25 feet |
| Attachments | Crevice Tool, Stair Tool | Crevice Tool, Dusting Brush |
| Brushroll On/Off | No | Yes |
| Swivel Steering | No | Yes |
Price and Availability
The Dyson DC17 is no longer in production but can sometimes be found through third-party retailers or refurbished sellers. Pricing can vary significantly based on condition and availability, typically ranging from $200 to $400.
The Shark NV26 Navigator is also an older model but may be available through various online retailers. Prices generally range from $100 to $200, making it a more affordable option.
Design and Build Quality
The Dyson DC17 features a robust and durable design, characteristic of Dyson products. It is constructed from high-quality plastics and designed to withstand regular use. However, its heavier weight (21.8 lbs) can make it less maneuverable compared to lighter models. The DC17’s design emphasizes functionality, with a focus on strong suction and effective filtration.
The Shark NV26 Navigator, weighing in at 15 lbs, prioritizes ease of use. Its lightweight design and swivel steering enhance maneuverability, allowing users to navigate around furniture and tight spaces with ease. While its build quality is not as premium as the Dyson DC17, it offers a practical and user-friendly design. The Shark NV26 navigator dust cup is also easier to empty and clean compared to the Dyson.
Performance and Features
Suction Power and Cleaning Performance
The Dyson DC17 is renowned for its powerful suction, thanks to its Root Cyclone technology. This technology effectively separates dirt and dust from the airflow, maintaining consistent suction power. In testing, the DC17 excels at lifting embedded dirt from carpets and rugs. Dyson DC17 is especially effective on high-pile carpets, where its strong suction can dislodge deeply trapped debris.
The Shark NV26 Navigator offers respectable suction power for its price range. While it may not match the raw power of the Dyson DC17, it performs well on both carpets and hard floors, particularly with the brushroll engaged. The brushroll shutoff feature prevents scattering on hard floors, enhancing its versatility.
Filtration System
The Dyson DC17 features a whole-machine HEPA filtration system, capturing 99.97% of allergens and particles as small as 0.3 microns. This makes it an excellent choice for allergy and asthma sufferers. The lifetime filter reduces maintenance costs, as it does not require frequent replacements.
The Shark NV26 Navigator uses a standard filtration system with washable filters. While effective at capturing larger particles, it does not offer the same level of filtration as the Dyson DC17’s HEPA system. Regular cleaning of the filters is necessary to maintain optimal performance.
Attachments and Accessories
The Dyson DC17 includes a crevice tool and a stair tool, providing basic cleaning versatility. The attachments are easy to connect and use, allowing for effective cleaning of edges, corners, and stairs.
The Shark NV26 Navigator comes with a crevice tool and a dusting brush. These attachments are useful for cleaning furniture, upholstery, and hard-to-reach areas. The dusting brush is particularly effective for gently cleaning delicate surfaces.
Battery Life
Since both the Dyson DC17 and Shark NV26 Navigator are corded vacuums, battery life is not applicable. The corded design ensures consistent power and eliminates the need to worry about charging or battery degradation over time.
Software and User Experience
Neither the Dyson DC17 nor the Shark NV26 Navigator includes software or smart features. Their operation is straightforward and intuitive, focusing on delivering a simple and effective cleaning experience. The absence of complex controls makes them easy to use for all users, regardless of technical proficiency.
Comparison to Competitors
- Dyson DC17 vs. Shark NV26 Navigator: The Dyson DC17 offers superior suction power and HEPA filtration, making it ideal for allergy sufferers and those with heavily soiled carpets. However, it is heavier and less maneuverable than the Shark NV26 Navigator. The Shark NV26 Navigator provides a more budget-friendly and versatile option with its lightweight design and brushroll shutoff feature.
- Shark NV26 Navigator vs. Bissell CleanView: The Shark NV26 Navigator is more maneuverable due to its swivel steering, while the Bissell CleanView often offers a larger dust cup capacity. Both are budget-friendly options, but the Shark NV26 Navigator’s brushroll shutoff gives it an edge on hard floors.
- Dyson DC17 vs. Newer Dyson Models (e.g., Dyson V11): While the Dyson DC17 boasts strong suction, newer Dyson cordless models like the V11 offer greater convenience and maneuverability. However, the DC17’s corded design ensures consistent power without the need for charging.
Pros and Cons
Dyson DC17
Pros:
- Superior suction power
- Whole-machine HEPA filtration
- Durable build quality
Cons:
- Heavy and less maneuverable
- Attachments are limited
- Dust cup can be difficult to empty
Shark NV26 Navigator
Pros:
- Lightweight and maneuverable
- Brushroll shutoff for hard floors
- More affordable
- Easy to empty dust cup
Cons:
- Suction power not as strong as Dyson
- Standard filtration system
- Build quality not as robust
Value for Money
Dyson DC17:
The Dyson DC17 offers excellent cleaning performance and advanced filtration, but its higher price point and heavier design may not be suitable for everyone. It is a good choice for those who prioritize powerful suction and HEPA filtration and don’t mind the added weight.
Shark NV26 Navigator:
The Shark NV26 Navigator provides a more budget-friendly and versatile option, making it a great value for those who need a lightweight and maneuverable vacuum. Its brushroll shutoff feature enhances its performance on hard floors, adding to its overall value.
Verdict
The choice between the Dyson DC17 and Shark NV26 Navigator depends on your specific needs and priorities. The Dyson DC17 excels in suction power and filtration, making it ideal for allergy sufferers and those with heavily soiled carpets. However, its weight and higher price point are drawbacks. The Shark NV26 Navigator offers a more affordable, lightweight, and versatile option, suitable for various floor types and users who prioritize maneuverability.
Given its balance of performance, versatility, and value, the Shark NV26 Navigator scores a 7.5/10.
