The Dyson DC14 and the Shark Navigator are two titans in the world of upright vacuums, each promising powerful suction and versatile cleaning capabilities. Both have earned a loyal following, but they cater to slightly different needs and preferences. The Dyson DC14, known for its cyclone technology and robust build, has been a long-standing favorite for tackling stubborn dirt and pet hair. On the other hand, the Shark Navigator boasts impressive maneuverability and a lift-away design, making it a strong contender for homes with diverse cleaning requirements. This review dives deep into the specifics of each vacuum, helping you determine which one best suits your cleaning arsenal.
Choosing the right vacuum cleaner can dramatically impact your cleaning routine. Whether you prioritize raw suction power, ease of use, or specialized features, understanding the strengths and weaknesses of each model is crucial. In this head-to-head comparison, we’ll examine the design, performance, features, and value proposition of the Dyson DC14 and the Shark Navigator to provide a comprehensive guide for making an informed decision.
Table of Contents
Key Takeaways
- Dyson DC14: Excels in suction power and durability, making it ideal for homes with heavy dirt and pet hair.
- Shark Navigator: Offers superior maneuverability and a convenient lift-away feature for versatile cleaning above floors.
- Filtration: The Dyson DC14 employs a washable HEPA filter, while the Shark Navigator relies on a sealed system with a HEPA filter, both effective at trapping allergens.
- Value: The Shark Navigator generally offers a better value proposition due to its lower price point and comparable performance in many areas.
- Verdict: While the Dyson DC14 offers exceptional power, the Shark Navigator strikes a better balance of performance, features, and affordability, earning it a slightly higher recommendation for most users.
Specifications
| Feature | Dyson DC14 | Shark Navigator |
|---|---|---|
| Type | Upright | Upright |
| Weight | 17.9 lbs | 12.5 lbs |
| Cord Length | 31 ft | 25 ft |
| Filtration | Washable HEPA Filter | Sealed HEPA System |
| Dustbin Capacity | 0.7 gallons | 1.2 quarts (approx. 0.3 gallons) |
| Cleaning Path Width | 13.5 inches | 9.5 inches |
| Attachments | Crevice Tool, Stair Tool | Crevice Tool, Dusting Brush |
| Swivel Steering | No | Yes |
| Lift-Away Feature | No | Yes |
| Technology | Root Cyclone Technology | Never Loses Suction Technology |
| Warranty | 5 years (limited) | 1 year (limited) |
| Power | 12 amps | 10 amps |
| Height | 48.4 inches | 45.7 inches |
| Model Number Example | DC14 | NV356E |
Price and Availability
The Dyson DC14 is an older model and may be harder to find new. Refurbished models are often available through various online retailers, typically priced between $200 and $300. The Shark Navigator, on the other hand, is widely available at major retailers like Amazon, Walmart, and Target, with prices ranging from $150 to $250 depending on the specific model and any ongoing promotions. Bundles that include additional attachments or extended warranties can also affect the price.
Given that the Dyson DC14 is an older model, its price might not always reflect its value compared to newer vacuums with similar capabilities. Checking multiple sources and considering the condition of the unit is crucial when purchasing a refurbished DC14. The Shark Navigator’s consistent availability and competitive pricing make it an easier and potentially more cost-effective option for many consumers.
Design and Build Quality
The Dyson DC14 is built like a tank, featuring a robust construction that feels durable and long-lasting. Its design is functional, with a clear emphasis on performance over aesthetics. The materials used are high-quality plastics that can withstand heavy use, and the overall impression is one of reliability. However, its heavier weight and lack of swivel steering can make it less maneuverable compared to newer models.
In contrast, the Shark Navigator is lighter and more agile, thanks to its swivel steering and lift-away design. While its build quality may not feel as substantial as the DC14, it is still well-constructed and designed for ease of use. The lift-away feature allows you to detach the canister for cleaning stairs and other hard-to-reach areas, adding to its versatility. The materials used in the Shark Navigator are lighter plastics, which contribute to its lower weight but may not offer the same level of durability as the Dyson DC14.
Performance and Features
Suction Power
The Dyson DC14 is renowned for its exceptional suction power, which is largely attributed to its Root Cyclone technology. This technology effectively separates dirt and debris from the airflow, preventing clogging and maintaining consistent suction. In testing, the DC14 consistently outperformed other vacuums in its class when it came to lifting embedded dirt and pet hair from carpets.
The Shark Navigator also boasts strong suction, thanks to its “Never Loses Suction” technology. While it may not match the raw power of the DC14, it is still highly effective at cleaning both carpets and hard floors. The Navigator’s suction control feature allows you to adjust the suction level for different surfaces, preventing delicate rugs from being pulled up.
Filtration System
Both the Dyson DC14 and the Shark Navigator feature HEPA filtration systems, making them suitable for allergy sufferers. The DC14 uses a washable HEPA filter, which can be easily cleaned and reused, reducing the need for replacements. The Shark Navigator employs a sealed system with a HEPA filter, ensuring that dust and allergens are trapped inside the vacuum rather than being released back into the air.
In terms of filtration effectiveness, both vacuums perform admirably. However, the Shark Navigator’s sealed system may offer a slight advantage in preventing allergen leakage. Regular maintenance of the filters is essential for both models to maintain optimal performance.
Attachments and Accessories
The Dyson DC14 typically comes with a crevice tool and a stair tool, which are useful for cleaning edges, corners, and upholstery. While these attachments are functional, they are relatively basic compared to the more extensive accessory kits offered with some other vacuums.
The Shark Navigator usually includes a crevice tool and a dusting brush, which provide similar cleaning versatility. However, some Navigator models may come with additional attachments, such as a pet power brush, which is particularly useful for removing pet hair from upholstery and carpets. The availability of these extra attachments can vary depending on the specific model and retailer.
Battery Life
Since both the Dyson DC14 and Shark Navigator are corded upright vacuums, battery life is not applicable.
Software and User Experience
Since both the Dyson DC14 and Shark Navigator are traditional upright vacuums, software and user experience are not applicable.
Comparison to Competitors
When compared to the Hoover WindTunnel T-Series, both the Dyson DC14 and Shark Navigator offer superior suction power and filtration. The Hoover WindTunnel is a budget-friendly option, but it lacks the advanced features and durability of the Dyson and Shark models. The Dyson DC14’s cyclone technology provides more consistent suction, while the Shark Navigator’s lift-away feature offers greater versatility.
Against the Bissell CleanView Swivel Rewind Pet Reach, the Shark Navigator holds its own with better maneuverability, especially with its swivel steering. The Bissell excels in pet hair removal with specialized brush rolls, but the Shark Navigator’s overall cleaning performance and ease of use make it a strong competitor. The Dyson DC14, while powerful, can feel cumbersome compared to the more agile Bissell and Shark models.
Pros and Cons
Dyson DC14
Pros:
- Exceptional suction power
- Durable build quality
- Washable HEPA filter
Cons:
- Heavy and less maneuverable
- Basic attachments
- May be difficult to find new
Shark Navigator
Pros:
- Lightweight and maneuverable
- Lift-away feature for versatile cleaning
- Sealed HEPA system
Cons:
- Build quality not as robust as Dyson
- Smaller dustbin capacity
- Shorter cord length
Value for Money
The Shark Navigator offers better value for money. Its lower price point, coupled with its versatile features and solid performance, makes it an attractive option for most consumers. The Dyson DC14, while offering superior suction power, may not justify its higher price tag, especially considering its age and the availability of newer, more feature-rich vacuums.
For budget-conscious shoppers who want a reliable and versatile vacuum, the Shark Navigator is the clear choice. The Dyson DC14 is better suited for those who prioritize raw power and durability and are willing to pay a premium for it.
Verdict
The Shark Navigator emerges as the winner in this head-to-head comparison. While the Dyson DC14 boasts impressive suction power and a robust build, the Shark Navigator’s superior maneuverability, lift-away feature, and lower price point make it a more practical and versatile choice for most households. Whether you’re tackling carpets, hard floors, or above-floor cleaning, the Shark Navigator offers a compelling combination of performance and convenience.
I would rate the Shark Navigator an 8.5/10.
